Allardyce questioned the accuracy of Carragher's claims, pointing out that it is not possible for a player's legs to suddenly deteriorate overnight, especially after a summer break. He also noted that Carragher's comments were similar to those he makes about other Liverpool players who are not performing well.

Allardyce's comments were made on a podcast, where he was discussing the claims made by Carragher. He emphasized the importance of having a deep understanding of the game and its players before making public statements.